Torbay councillors to review decision to scrap Blue Flag beach scheme

Torbay councillors will meet tomorrow to review a controversial decision to withdraw from the internationally recognised Blue Flag beach scheme.

The meeting follows a formal “call-in” of the council’s cabinet decision to replace Blue Flag accreditation with a locally run system known as the English Riviera Beach Standards (ERBS).

Members of the council’s Overview and Scrutiny Board will examine the decision and decide whether it should go ahead or be reconsidered.

The new framework, approved by cabinet earlier this year, would introduce a two-tier recognition system for Torbay’s beaches based on “Excellence” and “Quality” standards, alongside a designation for natural beaches.

Council leaders argue the locally developed system will better reflect Torbay’s coastline while maintaining high environmental and visitor standards.

According to the council’s report, the Blue Flag scheme has become “increasingly rigid, operationally restrictive and costly”, with requirements that are difficult to implement along Torbay’s coastline.

The report states the English Riviera Beach Standards would place greater emphasis on water quality, environmental protection, accessibility and visitor experience while allowing “proportionate, place-based management”.

However, several councillors have raised concerns and requested the decision be scrutinised further.

The call-in, proposed by Councillor Law and seconded by Councillor Douglas-Dunbar, questions whether adequate consultation took place before the policy was adopted.

Issues raised include whether organisations such as the Marine Conservation Society and Surfers Against Sewage were consulted, and what discussions were held with tourism businesses and attraction providers.

Councillors have also asked whether the council explored lobbying for reforms to the Blue Flag scheme or developing a regional alternative with other coastal authorities.

Further questions focus on the potential impact of withdrawing from the international scheme and the costs already incurred in developing the new framework.

During tomorrow’s meeting, the councillor who requested the call-in will outline their concerns before cabinet members respond.

The scrutiny board will then decide whether to take no further action, refer the decision back to cabinet for reconsideration, or in exceptional circumstances refer the issue to full council.