‘This is not democracy’ – councillors condemn new planning rules


North Devon councillors have criticised new government rules that will see more planning applications decided by officers and not a committee
A North Devon committee chair has hit out at new planning reforms which he says will hinder local councillors trying to represent their ward over planning applications and suppress local voices.
The chair of North Devon Council’s planning committee, Councillor Kevin Davies said new legislation which gives more decision making powers to officers did not fit all local authorities and “certainly not North Devon.”
The government is trying to accelerate its plan to build 1.5 million homes during its current term to help solve the housing crisis and wants to streamline the planning process.
It says around 96 per cent of planning applications are delegated to local planning officers already.
It is asking councils to change their constitution ahead of the new national scheme of delegation coming into play on October 31.
Under the rules, ‘schedule one’ applications which include householder developments such as extensions, minor residential development up to nine homes and small scale commercial expansions will not be decided by planning committees but by officers.
Cllr Davies said the presumption was that schedule two applications, which included major developments, would also be delegated to officers but would be subject to a ‘gateway test’ to decide if they should be escalated to committee.
Councillors will also lose their automatic power to “call in” applications to be heard by the committee.
Cllr Davies told North Devon’s full council meeting that just 12 of the 33 applications determined by the committee last year fell into schedule two.
He said: “Looking forward it is possible that very few applications will be dealt with by the committee at all. The new legislation mandated by government clearly does not fit all and certainly not North Devon.
“The sad truth is councillors will have their ability to represent their ward curtailed, their concerns unheard in public at committee, local views suppressed and ignored.
“Instead of ensuring healthy debate at committee with other members I will be spending time reviewing gateway tests with our planning manager.”
He questioned if the changes were to “focus on significant and strategically important development proposals” or because the planning committee was seen as “another obstacle in the planning process.”
He added: “I am proud to chair our planning committee and grateful for officer and member support and I value public input. The government is ill-informed and continues to be deluded in their promise of delivering 1.5 million homes.”
Cllr Davies said there was no choice but to approve changes to the council’s constitution or it would result in legal challenges to the council’s planning decisions and cost the authority money.
Cllr Graham Bell said he would be abstaining as the reforms “removed democracy and the right for people to be represented in the planning system.”
Cllr Becky Coombs (said: “This is being forced on us. The Labour government has no recognition of rurality.
“A planning development of nine or less homes can still be a major development in some areas that are rural and the public should have the right to attend a committee meeting and voice their objections or support to the members of that committee
“We are elected by communities to be their champion so should at least be given the right to make a case over why that application should come before committee but Labour is taking that away. This is not democracy.”
Nine members abstained and two voted against making changes to the constitution but 16 voted for it and so was carried.