Rugby row escalates, despite RFU apology


'Oops, sorry everyone - we got that wrong' - the Rugby Football Union has issued an humiliating apology after their attempt to impose a ban on tackling above the waist created an uproar in the grassroots game. Not only have the RFU admitted that their ha
'Oops, sorry everyone - we got that wrong' - the Rugby Football Union has issued an humiliating apology after their attempt to impose a ban on tackling above the waist created an uproar in the grassroots game.
Not only have the RFU admitted that their handling of the affair was botched, they have asked lower level clubs to get them out of the mess.
The introduction of the above-waist ban from National League level downwards, due to start in the summer, now appears to have been halted in the face of furious opposition, and a consultation process has been launched.
The RFU's latest statement, issued last weekend, apologised for the 'anger and concern' created by its handling of the affair.
It went on: "In our desire to act quickly…we have upset many of you who are the champions, volunteers and ambassadors of our game.
"We fully acknowledge that we got the engagement wrong, and we are truly sorry."
The ruling body says it's now starting a period of consultation, including 'forums and workshops' with players, coaches and match officials 'to help us define how we describe a lower tackle height to reflect what the research is telling us, in a way that is understood by all."
Tackling above chest-height is already banned.
The row, which exposed existing fault-lines between grassroots rugby and the top levels of the game, even sparked the formation of a new Community Clubs Union, as well as calls for RFU chief executive Bill Sweeney to resign.
An 'anti' petition attracted more than 50,000 signatures in its first 48 hours.
High-profile figures, including ex-players and referees like Nigel Owens MBE, expressed serious doubts over how the new law would work and whether it would actually reduce the head impacts which have attracted so much attention.
Okehampton 1st XV captain Dan Fogerty was one of many who did not mince their words in opposition to the change.
He described the RFU as 'disconnected', the tackle decision as 'a completely rushed reaction' and expressed fears of an exodus of players unwilling to continue under the new restrictions.
Fogerty said: "I think it just shows how disconnected the RFU is from the amateur game. They don't really know what's going on below the top levels.
"There are very few incidents at our level of head-to-head or shoulder-to-head contact.
"You have far more incidents of knee to head, and this new law would increase those impacts.
"It's a professional problem which they've panicked over, to make it look as if they're doing something. It's a completely rushed reaction.
"How a big second-row forward is going to tackle a little No.9, I don't know.
"And what are you supposed to do when the opposition is trying to drive over your line? You can't get any lower, so do you just stand back and let them do it?"
Fogerty, who says his player-coach Richard Bolt supports him, adds: "I've not heard a positive comment.
"I know a lot of older boys are saying 'I won't play if this goes through'.
"If every club loses ten players, it could be the end for some of them. And nearly every person who's now playing rugby professionally has come through the lower levels.
"Everybody who goes on to a rugby pitch knows the risks. It's like getting in your car every day - there are risks to that, but we all do it.
"And what about the poor referees? Their job is hard enough as it is, with no linesmen at many lower level games."
The problem for the RFU is that their apology might come too late for many in the game, as it is not only the concern tackle-height changes that will have on the local game, but also the worry that this episode has shown the authorities to be painfully out of touch with rugby players, coaches and supporters.
Safety is obviously crucially important in the running but so is collaboration, communication, cohesion and consultation.