Argyle’s cup fightback falls short as Coventry survive Home Park scare

Plymouth Argyle v Coventry Cityplaceholder image
Plymouth Argyle v Coventry City | Dave Rowntree/PPAUK

Plymouth Argyle just fall short against Premier League Coventry City

Plymouth Argyle produced a spirited fightback at Home Park but ultimately bowed out of the Carabao Cup as Premier League Coventry City recovered from a two-goal collapse to seal a place in the third round.

Argyle looked to be facing a long night after Coventry struck twice inside the opening five minutes, but the Pilgrims refused to buckle and hauled themselves level before the visitors finally found the extra quality to settle the tie.

Coventry needed only three minutes to break the deadlock. Liam Kitching's forward pass released Taiwo Awoniyi after a clever flick from Caleb Yirenkyi, with the former Nottingham Forest striker keeping his composure to finish past the Argyle defence.

The Premier League visitors doubled their advantage just two minutes later.

Awoniyi turned provider this time, getting in front of Wes Harding before picking out Jack Rudoni, who calmly slotted home to give Frank Lampard's side what appeared to be a commanding early lead.

Argyle, though, responded with plenty of character.

Oliver Irow, making his debut after arriving on loan from Tottenham, gave the Home Park crowd something to cheer about in the 21st minute. The youngster drove forward before firing a low finish into the net to put Argyle back in the contest.

The hosts continued to grow into the game and were rewarded again shortly after half-time.

Xavier Amaechi, introduced as a substitute at the interval, put Coventry under pressure in the 54th minute, closing down a hesitant Kitching and winning possession. He then raced through before sending a low shot into the bottom corner to bring the scores level.

For a spell, Argyle had turned a seemingly hopeless position into a genuine cup upset.

But Coventry regrouped and regained the lead in the 67th minute.

Victor Torp recycled possession before sending a low ball into the penalty area, where substitute Ephron Mason-Clark bundled the ball home just five minutes after being introduced.

Argyle were then handed another blow when Joe Edwards clipped Coventry forward Brandon Thomas-Asante as the Plymouth substitute attempted to clear, leaving referee Elliott Swallow with little choice but to award a penalty.

Torp made no mistake from the spot in the 78th minute, finding the top corner to finally put the result beyond Argyle.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice