IAN ROOME: Pause on Devon's 'sprawling mess' of a council shake-up gives us a chance to do better


With the government putting its controversial local government overhaul on ice, North Devon MP Ian Roome argues that ministers were right to bin a flawed plan that risked pushing local decision-making further away from local communities.
Devon’s future has been turned on its head for the second time in just six weeks, after the government announced a surprise halt to its plans to reorganise our council areas.
Speaking to baffled MPs, Secretary of State for Local Government Angela Rayner – now back in the same job she left barely a year ago – announced that the government would think again, in light of new legal advice.
Be thankful for small mercies. Under the plan announced in July, Devon’s overlapping county and district councils would have been swept aside for new Exeter, Plymouth, and Torbay councils, each taking territory from their immediate surroundings.
However, for the rest of Devon, lumped into a giant rural Devon council nearly 70 miles across, the plan was a sprawling mess. The new council would have immediately become one of the largest anywhere in the country, stretching as far as Ilfracombe to Kingsbridge, Holsworthy to Axminster – and almost certainly moving local services, councillors, and decision-making further away from local residents.
The government’s plans are now ‘under review’, and what happens to Devon next is uncertain. Nobody knows if the old plan will return like a bad penny next summer, or if a new Prime Minister will demand everyone go back to the drawing board.
The government may have backed themselves into a corner. A rival plan, agreed by seven of Devon’s district councils, proposed a compromise between rural and urban Devon, prioritising financial stability, existing transport corridors, and something that at least made sense on a map.
Instead, by giving Labour-controlled Exeter and Plymouth exactly what they asked for, the process looked and smelled politically motivated. With that plan in doubt just a few weeks later, ministers have left Labour politicians in Exeter and Plymouth looking sheepish.
So we should be glad the new Prime Minister’s government have seen sense. We must now hope that the government listens and prioritises the concerns of local communities right across Devon, instead of flogging a proposal rejected by 69 per cent of those who took part in the public consultation.
Most frustratingly, time and public money has already been lost. In preparation for this shake-up, Devon’s councils will have already dedicated days and weeks of staff time to thrash out the details of everything from how to transfer council assets, to redrawing electoral wards and keeping services running during a transition. Everything from buses to bins, buildings to business rates will all have to be tackled.
Devon County Council estimated that the cost of implementing the government’s new model could have approached £90 million. Councils across the country have already spent millions of pounds on their reorganisations, and we can only hope the hard work of council staff here in Devon will not have been wasted entirely.
Ministers have promised to meet with rural Devon MPs, and we will be making the case for a model that benefits both rural and urban communities. My Liberal Democrat colleague Caroline Voaden MP launched a petition which instantly collected more than 1,500 signatures from South Devon residents, shocked by the bizarre proposal of Salcombe being in the same council area as Ilfracombe.
Local government should be genuinely local to the people it serves. People rightly expect accountability for roads and planning decisions, social care, and everything else that makes everyday life possible.
The government’s first draft has gone in the recycling bin; there is still time to do better.