‘Wasted money to private companies’: North Devon councillor condemns cost of Devon child services


A North Devon councillor has criticised Devon County Council paying ‘top money for poor outcomes’ to private companies for child care placements. Fremington county councillor Frank Biederman was speaking at a full meeting of DCC on Thursday (February 16)
A North Devon councillor has criticised Devon County Council paying ‘top money for poor outcomes’ to private companies for child care placements.
Fremington county councillor Frank Biederman was speaking at a full meeting of DCC on Thursday (February 16) which saw the council’s annual budget passed by 40 to 13 votes, with an 18.4 per cent increase in spending on child services.
The council’s children’s services were rated ‘inadequate’ by Ofsted in 2020 and a recent visit by inspectors in December (CLICK HERE for their report) still found ‘serious issues’ and not enough progress, although it did highlight some positives.
Speaking at the budget vote, Cllr Biederman said people would think a 18.4 per cent increase in spending for children’s services compared with 3.5 for highways would be ‘a good news story for children’.
Instead he said: “But on closer inspection our children are also failed, just like the roads and footpaths, I am not convinced that there is a solid plan for the extra to improve outcomes, and Ofsted are definitely not convinced.
“All I see is lots of council tax payers’ money being poured into private care providers.”
Referring to how the ‘near £209million’ allocated would be spent and giving one example, he said independent care placements, across independent residential care, post 18 residential care and independent supported accommodation costs would rises from £27.6m to £39.1m, an £11.4m increase.
Cllr Biederman said that was for a forecasted rise of 15 young people to 162.
He asked: “I appreciate with inflation at 10-12 per cent that there would be a rise, but really, a 41.4 per cent rise of £11.5m to care for an extra 15 children?
“This averages out at £241,759,259 each for the 162 young people we accommodate.
“Someone is doing really well? Who are these private providers? I would like to know? How many that we use are not registered with Ofsted as mentioned by Ofsted in the monitoring visit last month? What are their profits?
“What happened to providing and increasing our internal residential offer that we were told would be coming for several years.”
He also referred to fostering, which he said saw internal placements run by the council costing £27,484 per child yet external foster placements cost £56,380.
He said in-house placements had reduced from 415 to 386 and its budget increase by £284,000 to £10.6m.
External foster placements had increased by three children to 163, with a £1.18m increase to £9.19m.
He asked: “A difference of £28,896 per child and we are decreasing in-house and increasing independent placements?
“Would we be doing this if it was our business or personal costs?”
Ofsted’s recent visit found children in local authority care still had too much uncertainty surrounding their situation, there was not enough assessment or support packages in place for those living with other family members.
It also said some children living in children’s homes were not registered with Ofsted, plus the quality of social work was ‘variable’ across the region.
Cllr Biederman said: “So we are paying top money for poor outcomes for the most vulnerable children we serve and are corporate parents of, while next door Cornwall are judged as doing a fantastic job for vulnerable children, I don’t have sight of their budgets, but I would be interested to know if they are comparable to the £241,000 per head we are paying.
“A social worker tells me all their managers in north area are agency staff and they have had five different managers this year - we have not even had that many chancellors.
“What does this do for the morale of front line children’s staff? How much of the £209m is spent on agency workers?
“Surely paying and investing in our own amazing social workers is a better way to recruit and keep them, giving children security/consistency and the feeling of love they all desire and deserve after being brought into our care.
“Let’s be honest, various cabinet members and senior leaders have failed, we go around in circles, we shuffle the pack but again and again the budget goes up and the outcomes for the children in our care remains poor and it’s other services that suffer as we continue to throw money at a failing service.”