Rumours developers will no longer be required to build affordable homes - Tim Jones

placeholder image

If you thought that the government had done enough to disturb us with their mini budget, please think again. We are just being notified that a major change is in the system for planning reform. This will be more than just tinkering around the edges. There

If you thought that the government had done enough to disturb us with their mini budget, please think again. We are just being notified that a major change is in the system for planning reform. This will be more than just tinkering around the edges. There are some significant structural alterations planned.

It is always difficult to predict exactly what might finally be presented, particularly with a government who are having to learn quickly about media statements and who are desperately keen not to be embarrassed by another major U-turn.

In fairness to the government, had it not been for the chaos caused by the mini budget and the complete failure to catch the public mood and also that of the business and financial markets, then broadly I would have been applauding the need for a root and branch review of the planning system.

Planning has been a huge and controversial area for many years. At best, the current system can be described as dysfunctional. In practice this means that crucial planning decisions are not made quickly, thereby holding back wealth creating opportunities and invariably the creations of jobs, both during the construction phase and for the long term. In short, planning needs to be a slick, efficient service. This does not mean it should be a developers charter. Nor that we should be compromising our precious environmental standards for the sake of a scheme which has significant economic benefits.

What is happening in reality is so complex and entangled that decisions are very seldom made in a timely manner. Too often it is a lottery as to whether good schemes are approved. Inevitably this means that some bad schemes have slipped through the net.

The reason why the planning system has become gridlocked are many and complex. It is no criticism of Local Authorities that these problems have arisen. Central funding from government has meant that planning departments have 20% less cash to run on than they had five years ago. There are huge issues regarding the number of skilled planning officers who are available in the market. There are huge problems about recruitment generally. Many experienced senior officers are either head hunted or too often become the victims of unacceptable workloads and make the sad decision of taking early retirement in order to re-establish an acceptable lifestyle.

Some of the figures regarding time delays in approving schemes are alarming. There is supposed to be a maximum period of 13 weeks for major applications to be processed. In reality, most major applicants will describe a process which has taken between 9-12 months to navigate.

One national house builder recently stated that on average it was taking them between 3-4 years to get from the submission of a planning application to a start on site. It would be easy to pick up some of the miss-information which is often peddled by politicians that house builders simply land bank sites.

This could not be further from the truth. All housebuilders need to secure a quick return on their capital expenditure. They can only get this return by committing to developing out sites. In 90% of the cases we have reviewed locally that have a positive planning allocation but are stalled, there are technical or legal reasons why they are unable to proceed.

The sum total of all of this is that development does not happen. Wealth and job creation does not occur. Critically also, much needed open market and affordable housing accommodation is not provided. This is a tragedy for many trying to get onto the housing ladder. In too many cases this also prevents local companies growing because they cannot get staff who can live locally.

It is against this background that planning reforms are long overdue.

Successive governments have tried and failed on many occasions to implement changes. These have often fallen at the first hurdle because they have been regarded as a carte blanche for developers, an affront to the environmental lobby or simply contrary to the army of those who are described as Nimbys.

What we are told is likely to be on the table is a speeding up of the planning process (difficult to achieve without a lot more money being available to improve delivery systems).

A relaxation of the need for every small housing site to deliver a fixed percentage affordable housing (this will be controversial but is an attempt to encourage local house builders to access the market).

There is likely to be an extension to something called Permitted Development Rights, which means that there is an automatic assumption that certain types of projects do not have to go through the normal planning processes. A good example of this would be a tired office building, for which there is no demand, being converted into residential accommodation.

Additional areas of change may include logical opportunities where extensions to existing properties are proposed (the addition of a third or fourth bedroom, office annex, garage etc). Another important proposal might be moving away from arbitrary targets which have been set for an area.

Currently each District has to deliver a set number of houses within a five year period. Often these targets have changed since the numbers were calculated. Too often this leaves the Local Authorities unable to deliver the five year land supply, allowing other sites to be introduced which are less appropriate and where consent is obtained through a planning appeal process (yet more cost incurred by the public purse).

Many have anticipated that these changes will dumb down on environmental improvements and also reduce the need to deliver Net Zero target dates. This is simply not the case. Nowhere in the proposed legislation is this suggested. If anything, the plans are to reinforce these provisions whilst making them simpler to implement.

I have to declare a personal conflict as I have interests in the property world. Importantly, however, I have a passion for the environment, it is perfectly possible to combine good quality development with high environmental standards whilst achieving buildings which are nice to look at with decent green space around them

I do therefore welcome a thorough debate when we see the fine print shortly. I will be very pleased to receive any feedback readers might have on these proposals, so that as and when a planning bill finally reaches the end of its journey through Whitehall, there are acceptable improvements taking onboard all of your collective inputs.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice