Housing to be defining issue at next General Election - Tim Jones

placeholder image

This subject is becoming a highly contentious and politically toxic issue. Many are now predicting that so serious is the problem of access to affordable housing units, first time buyer accommodation and rental properties, that this could be one of the de

This subject is becoming a highly contentious and politically toxic issue. Many are now predicting that so serious is the problem of access to affordable housing units, first time buyer accommodation and rental properties, that this could be one of the defining issues for the forthcoming general election (2024).

In previous comments on this topic, I have highlighted some of the issues that are affecting delivery. There are a complex number of reasons that are contributing to the problem. The brief experience we had when Liz Truss was Prime Minister disrupted the financial market, causing a deep impact on the cost of mortgages.

Prior to that, a shortage of construction workers and alarming increases in building material costs had already started to affect what used to be a very efficient market where supply and demand were in balance. Michael Gove’s department then threw a huge spanner in the works in order to placate a vocal group of Tory MPs in the red wall seat constituencies, by removing mandatory housing delivery targets and making these advisory only. Many describe this as a nimby charter.

Over the last few weeks the rhetoric has become a lot more volatile. It is clear that the current system is badly broken.

The game of finger pointing is now popular. The latest announcement is a good illustration of the nature of these problems. Whilst this particular example is not yet impacting upon delivery in Northern Devon, there is a very real chance that it could in the near future unless checks and balances are put in place to curb the delivery barriers.

Firmly in the dock is now Natural England. This body nestles under the umbrella of the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs. Its principal remit is for the protection of landscape.

Following new laws imposed by them, the Home Builders Federation has warned that the latest rules and changes to planning policy are threatening to reduce the number of new houses to be built from the total in 2018/ 19 of 240,000 a year to 111,000 by 2025. This needs to be measured against the government’s own target of building 300,000 houses a year.

These rules have already had a huge impact across the UK. Currently 74 Local Authorities have been forced to block new developments that could not show they would not pollute water systems. Natural England are now being directly accused of blocking around 160,000 new homes and reducing house building to its lowest level since the 1920s.

The technical arguments behind this are all to do with “nutrient neutrality”. These guidelines originated from a 2018 European Court of Justice ruling. To get planning consent in water vulnerable areas developers must show that new homes will not lead to more phosphates and nitrates running into rivers, thereby potentially encouraging dangerous algae and toxic bacteria which could stifle eco systems.

The whole basis of this regulation is the subject of scientific investigation. Many believe that the results are flawed. There is also compelling evidence that the guilty party is not the house builder but agricultural practices, which generate huge quantities of these potentially dangerous chemicals from the use of fertilisers and poor practice of controlling animal slurry. Bizarrely these uses are excluded from the Natural England rules.

It gets worse. Natural England have not come up with any sensible or financially logical solutions as to how these problem can be resolved. One of their suggestions is simply bonkers, which is an off-setting scheme whereby perfectly good agricultural land is turned into new woodland and wetland that can absorb nutrients. These perfectly good farms then need to be set aside for this use for a minimum of 90 years.

In some areas, such as Somerset, all new housing development has been blocked for nearly three years. In desperation, house builders are now being forced to spend tens of thousands of pounds even to build a single home. Inevitably, this is making development unviable or unaffordable for the new houses.

This is also suppressing supply and forcing up the values of existing properties. It is currently estimated that the UK economy has suffered a loss of activity of around £30 billion. Also, that around 500,000 fewer jobs are being supported in the construction industry.

Natural England started to impose these rules a couple of years ago, buoyed up by their success in getting one over on the development industry, they have now doubled the land areas to which these rules apply. There is no doubt they have more up their sleeve, which is why we need to worry about this issue.

The government have been slow to recognise this problem despite the fact that they should be able to control this agency. They have introduced some weak need solutions, which include allocating £30 million of funding to come up with a solution for nutrient mitigation schemes, and also to impose legal duties on water companies to upgrade waste water treatment works by 2030, thereby removing harmful chemicals before they reach water courses. These solutions of course are obviously unlikely to produce an answer any time soon. In a worst case scenario, new housing development could be blocked until 2030.

There is also no guarantee that science will come up with an adequate answer. Defra also appear not to be brave enough to suggest that poor farming practices should be addressed, which would dramatically reduce these problems. We all want a competitive agricultural industry but we also desperately need good quality and affordable housing accommodation. The battle lines for this hugely contentious debate are now being drawn. We need to respond to this to ensure that these problems do not affect delivery across Northern Devon.

Written by Tim Jones, Chairman of the North Devon Biosphere Foundation

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice