House Prices - What's really happening? - Tim Jones


It would be logical to assume that the market for houses generally (new and second hand) would have taken a dive as a result of inflationary pressures, increased interest rates, lower disposable incomes and a general lack of confidence. Indeed the stateme
It would be logical to assume that the market for houses generally (new and second hand) would have taken a dive as a result of inflationary pressures, increased interest rates, lower disposable incomes and a general lack of confidence. Indeed the statement from the Governor of the Bank of England Andrew Bailey warning that we should be preparing for a prolonged recession and inflation topping 13% also strongly suggests that a serious property market correction is long overdue. Surprisingly, and perhaps sadly, this is not yet the case.
Following the recent increase in interest rates by the Bank of England, it is now estimated that a first time buyer will be spending on average approximately 40% of their income on mortgage repayments. The calculation is that average monthly payments for a new homeowner will increase to more than £1,000 up from £813 in January. Some data shows that the average house price is seven times greater than typical earnings, the highest recorded ratio since 1983.
Even more disturbing, it seems that the average age of a first time buyer is creeping towards 40 years old. Leaving those below this age to rely upon the rental market or the goodwill of family and friends.
In all, not a good or healthy position.
If you look further at these figures they make grizzly reading. What has been a red hot market just refuses to dampen down. Prices rose at an annual rate of 11% last month slightly up from 10.7% in June. This takes the average price to £271,209, a hike of £55,000 more than in February 2020 before the pandemic. This is the 12th consecutive monthly rise.
These average UK wide prices disguise local variations. So for Northern Devon the average price rose by 20.8% over the year to £332,938 the 7th highest increase in the UK (South Hams up £17.7% to £405,599 and West Devon up only 4% to £288,604). This of course has a knock on effect on rental levels.
Here again supply is a huge problem with many landlords also enjoying healthy returns from holiday lets or AirBnB.
Those expecting all the dislocation of global economic markets to start influencing prices might have to wait until early next year. Demand generally for home buying has reduced over the last 12 months but remains 25% above the 5 year average, even despite inflation running at a 40 year high.
To some extent the pandemic was a major factor in stimulating a desire to move house and also the proposition of more flexible working hours (either working from home or on a hybrid basis). The simple fact however is that there is a shortage of housing stock, particularly for first time buyers and for affordable housing accommodation.
This imbalance is unlikely to change quickly. It may be the case that price levels will flatten out but that a dip in values is unlikely before the end of 2023.
Any talk of a market crash or double digit price falls are totally unwarranted. Even the most seasoned analysts have been surprised at the level of demand and general market take-up. Overall house sales this year will reach an estimated 1.3 million properties, which is approximately 100,000 more than was originally forecast at the beginning of 2022.
It is interesting to note that those seeking a better work-life balance are prepared to invest heavily despite the economic pressures arising from this. It seems that those working from home are 5 times more likely to move than those who have not seen any changes in their work patterns. Another concerning statistic is that the estimated 500,000 older people, who have left the labour market during the pandemic, are contributing to these trends with retirement being a major motivation for moving house.
So let us suppose that there is a big market correction and a house price crash. The last time this happened was after the financial sector meltdown in 2008. Then the average house price fell from £188,657 to £159,340 - a drop of 15% in a year. But even after such a huge financial crisis those house prices had recovered to £174,765 within 12 months.
All this makes depressing reading. There can be no doubt that Devon as a whole has a housing crisis. This is acute in Northern Devon and bluntly there are no easy solutions. Our Local Authorities are doing their best to tackle this but every month that goes by creates another problem for a potential first time buyer, key worker or someone with acute housing needs.
Such is the seriousness of this that it needs/deserves a whole community approach. I wonder if we would be up for a major public debate to examine potential solutions?
Rashly I am prepared to go out on a limb and say that if I was a first time buyer I would wait until January before diving in, it defies logic that by then prices will not have dipped.