“Economic backwater” fears for North Devon

Cllr Peter Jones. Image courtesy: North Devon Councilplaceholder image
Cllr Peter Jones. Image courtesy: North Devon Council

Council wants to be "part of the conversation"

There are fears that North Devon could become an “economic backwater” if the county’s large centres of population lead the way in the reorganisation of local government.

At a special meeting to discuss the government’s white paper on devolution, North Devon councillors opposed a single unitary authority for the county.

They pressed for a need to work with other councils to find a better solution.

They also don’t agree with postponing May’s county council elections, which the county council this week asked the government to approve.

Councillors have to submit proposals for devolution to the government by May or pledge to join a Devolution Priority Programme, which will give them until the autumn.

Just before Christmas, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner announced plans to create larger unitary authorities overseeing populations of around 500,000.

These authorities would replace the current district and county structure that exists in Devon.

Some city-based areas, such as Exeter, would be allowed to become unitaries if they make a strong enough case.

These councils would sit under large strategic authorities of 1.5 million people and an elected mayor.

The aim is to devolve power from Whitehall, with local areas holding the purse strings instead of bidding for central funds.

The proposal currently being supported among several councils in Devon is for a strategic authority that includes Devon, Cornwall, and the unitary authorities of Plymouth and Torbay.

However, how local government will look underneath that overarching authority is anyone’s guess right now.

Exeter has made a bid to the government for unitary status, and Plymouth wants to extend its boundaries.

East Devon proposes to split Devon into two—an east/north area around Exeter and a west/south area including Plymouth.

The move to speed up devolution and local government reform has left district councils concerned for the future.

North Devon councillor Paul Crabb (Con, Ilfracombe) said with Plymouth being a Labour council, it had “a back channel” to the government and claimed it had plans to take its population up to 350,000 by extending into the present South Hams District Council area.

Labour-run Exeter City Council, with a population of 130,000, would take some of East Devon, said Cllr Crabb, to meet the requirements of a unitary council.

“We need to make sure we are part of the conversation now so devolution is not done to us,” he said.

Cllr Robin Milton (Ind, Bishops Nympton) said the fast pace of the government’s plans would “provide some virtually insurmountable challenges for district and county councils, especially that confusion of where we stick Plymouth, Torbay, and Exeter, and everyone vying for their biggest slice of the pie.

“We potentially could, if we are not careful, become an economic backwater. We are up in one corner with a relatively low population.”

He said North Devon Council is “financially quite solvent” and had invested in economic regeneration.

“My concern in super-sized unitary authorities is that we could easily see asset stripping of what we have got here. The balance of power will be with the bigger populations.

“We cannot sit down and wonder where we are going to end up; we need to sit up on the bridge and say this is what we want out of this. We want a fair say in it.”

Cllr Peter Jones (Ind, Witheridge) said he was worried that local communities would lose out when the reforms come in.

“What we are talking about is moving politicians further away from the people. Those people who are most vulnerable and most in need, who are calling us as district councillors, who are they going to reach out to?

“They are going to be dependent on a unitary councillor, with a bigger area, who is not going to understand the dynamics of those communities or know the people.

“District councillors work really hard, and in my short time as a councillor I see how they and officers really push to do the absolute best they can to serve the area.

“The challenges for the county are very different. The burdens are so much greater; you have to think about all the different things they have to do.

“Funding needed for vital services is lost on bigger duties, and having districts really does protect those communities and the most vulnerable.”

Cllr David Worden (Lib Dem, South Molton) said it is time for a reorganisation of local government because local authorities don’t get enough money for things like pothole repairs.

But he said if this is purely a money-saving venture by the government, which could result in fewer staff and councillors, it is wrong as “services are going to go right down the drain.”

Members agreed that county council elections should take place in May in the interests of local democracy so the public can vote for who they feel can take devolution forward.

Cllr Pru Maskell (Con, Braunton West and Georgeham), who is also a county councillor, said the county voted in favour of postponing local elections because it would be too much for new councillors to learn the ropes as well as deal with the reorganisation.

North Devon Council will form a working group to consider local government reorganisation options.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice