Historic underfunding of North Devon 'just isn't fair' - David Worden

placeholder image

In an ideal world no-one should be disadvantaged by where they live in the UK. That should be a fundamental principle of government policy but unfortunately this isn’t the case. For years the government funding support received for public services in rur

In an ideal world no-one should be disadvantaged by where they live in the UK. That should be a fundamental principle of government policy but unfortunately this isn’t the case.

For years the government funding support received for public services in rural areas like North Devon is much lower per head of population than that received by those who live in cities.

As a result, those public services and the residents, businesses and communities who rely on them are greatly disadvantaged. This means that councils like ours have to take decisions which we don’t want to do like put up car parking charges or we wouldn’t be able to maintain our important services.

In fact it is a double whammy as it is not just that rural areas like ours receive less funding; it also costs more to provide services to a rural population. This fact is widely admitted but not sufficiently reflected in the various funding formulae used to distribute national funds to support local services.

Residents who live in rural areas like North Devon and Torridge pay on average 20% more in council tax per head than their urban counterparts. Even then the total funding power of rural areas is still less than urban areas, because they receive less money from central government. In 2023/24, urban areas will receive 59% more in government grants per head than rural ones. This just isn’t fair.

It results in rural residents paying more but getting fewer services. In addition rural wages are on average much lower than those in the country as a whole. At the same time the cost of living is higher in places like North Devon. On top of that we are forced to pay more for our local services through council tax. It is time this was changed.

What is so annoying is that under the government’s Provisional Settlement proposals, the gap in funding between rural and urban areas will, in fact increase still further. There is therefore a continuation of historic underfunding and unfairness for communities like ours. In 2012 the government seemed to acknowledge the problem and changed the local government funding formula. Unfortunately this hasn’t been fully implemented but has been blocked by a process called ‘damping’.

The Rural Services Network’s (RSN) analysis of the Provisional Settlement proposals shows in 2023/24 rural residents in comparison to residents in urban areas will, on average:

  • Pay £109.73 (20.3%) per head more in Council Tax
  • Get some £111 (59.4%) per head less from Settlement Funding Assessment (SFA) (general grant)
  • Get £8.41 (13) per head less in Social Care Services Grant
  • (Despite all of the above) still have over 38% less overall Spending Power per head.

London is getting some £236M a year more in Government Grant than the formula says it should (of which £166M is received by only 5 boroughs) – this at the expense of rural

and non-London local authorities. The Rural Services Delivery Grant (RSDG) was at £85M in 2020/21 (and still is at that level). £85M should, as presently assessed, be £96.27M in 2023/24 to reflect inflation.

Due to their underfunding, Rural Councils in 2022/23 were only able to budget to spend £67.00 per head on so-called discretionary services such as providing public toilets whilst urban areas budgeted to spend almost twice that (£131.31 per head). In my opinion discretionary services are important.

We need support for bus services, community support, support to the local charitable and voluntary sector, provision of sport, leisure and cultural activities and economic and community development. These are all classed as discretionary spending and are being cut back.

They are important for our wellbeing and without them are likely to put even more pressure on the over stretched NHS. When national resources are scarce it is more important than ever that those resources are distributed fairly. I agree entirely with the RSN calling for the existing formula to be fully funded from 2023/24. This doesn’t require any new monies to be found but simply a fair distribution.

If the government treated North Devon fairly it would make setting our element of the council tax so much easier in February as now we are faced with trying to eliminate a £2,000,000 budget gap.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice