Fuel prices - is it time to crack down on the profiteering? - Tim Jones


One of the penalties we accept in living in a predominantly rural area, is that almost inevitably we are completely dependent upon a car for personal mobility and access to work. There are of course some excellent public transport alternatives. The Tarka
One of the penalties we accept in living in a predominantly rural area, is that almost inevitably we are completely dependent upon a car for personal mobility and access to work.
There are of course some excellent public transport alternatives. The Tarka Line is a brilliant example of this but our confidence has been shaken by the seemingly never ending round of strikes. Our bus services also make a valuable contribution.
At the end of the day, however, probably 90 per cent of our travel decisions are dependent upon a motor car.
It is one of my personal bug bears, in travelling across the whole of the South West region, that I see huge discrepancies in the price of fuel. My irritation is probably something you would understand, when one brand of supermarket has a 0.7p differential between their pump prices despite only being 10 miles apart.
We also know that profiteering is endemic to the business. Look only at the pump prices on stations serving our main arterial road network, particularly when approaching or during peak holiday periods.
What a way to treat loyal customers and our valued visitors! I may be alone in this but even the thought of filling up at a motorway services is unimaginable, such is the obscene price levels that these operators seem comfortable to charge.
All this of course, comes at a time when we have never been more conscious about the erosion of our personal wealth and the need for very tight cash management.
Inflation is at a 40-year high. Food prices have gone up at to levels we would never have anticipated. I need not rehearse the problems we are experiencing with our energy bills.
Add to this the cost of fuel and it is easy to understand that we might feel that the world is against us.
Fuel vendors break into three groups – supermarkets, national brands and Independents. We must recognise that many of independents do a huge service for remoter communities. They are providing an essential service.
Invariably, because of their buying power, they are probably only able to secure fuel at prices that some of the major brands can retail it at. Those who therefore need to be challenged are the supermarkets and main brand operators.
We are familiar with the concept that fuel prices experience so called ‘rocket and feather’ pricing.
Seasoned observers know that the base price is set by (predominantly) Brent Crude. This is almost completely controlled by major oil producers – Middle East, Russia and others.
Whilst we might wish to question their morale judgement and social values, this is a pretty fruitless exercise as they will do exactly what they want to swell their already over-filled coffers.
Against this background, it is encouraging that one of the arms of Government – the Competition and Markets Authority – have been taking evidence, for the first time, into this highly volatile market where, over the last six months, price rises of around 0.50p per Litre have been common place, particularly for diesel.
This investigation will be thorough and will look back to the annual gross profit margins made by fuel retailers over the past five years. It will provide an objective assessment of whether this is price fixing, the result of weak competition or a rise in operating costs.
Some of the evidence of this is compelling, such as, my example above of the retailer who felt “comfortable” about charging 0.7p more in one store than one 10 miles away.
There can be no question that this could be the result of operating costs and is simply therefore a function of weak competition.
In trying to understand these issues in more detail, I have satisfied myself that there are no concerns here with the refining sector. Indeed, there is clear evidence that the refiners are earning low or negative margins on average since 2020, despite the spike to record high prices this year.
That jump, of around 0.50p per litre between January 2022 and July 2022, is the largest recorded increase in any one year.
It is also equally bizarre that there is an increasing gap between petrol and diesel prices currently averaging around 0.24p per litre.
The Competition Authority has already indicated that, as part of their investigation, they will be exploring how quickly wholesale price rises or falls are passed on to customers. Early indications are that it is taking double the time to pass on falling prices when compared with price rises (average six weeks).
There can be no doubt that we are in almost unchartered territory regarding what will happen next with fuel prices. The pressures here include Net Zero targets (electric vehicles), increased accessibility to alternative bio-fuels, the effect of the recession in suppressing demand, the effect of the sanctions on Russia who are a major oil supplier, the impact of the conflict in Ukraine and of the impact of what is likely to be a global recession.
The predictions are however that there will be a massive downward shift in the price of wholesale fuel. What is less certain is how quickly this will be reflected in forecourt prices.
How nice it is to record that Northern Devon is one of the most progressive areas within the huge region I cover. For the last month, a fuel station in Barnstaple has been the cheapest within a 100 mile radius.
This has, of course, affected nearby competitors, giving the residents and businesses within our area some relief from the price pressures we are experiencing.
Let us hope that the Competition Authority use their powers to enforce change. In the interim, let us enjoy the fact that some of our local entrepreneurs are seeking to set much more realistic pricing policies in support of our local economy.