Does Northern Devon have a shortage of construction workers? - Tim Jones


You will have read many articles recently and heard news coverage about skills shortages generally throughout the UK. We all have our own experiences of how difficult it is to recruit and retain the right staff. There are many complex reasons behind this
You will have read many articles recently and heard news coverage about skills shortages generally throughout the UK.
We all have our own experiences of how difficult it is to recruit and retain the right staff. There are many complex reasons behind this. Undoubtedly Brexit had a major effect when we lost access to many who had been regular contributors to fill our skills gap from across Europe – hospitality, farming and construction.
There is also believed to be a hangover from the effects of Covid, where many either are still suffering from the effects of this or have had to become a permanent carer for family members who have been affected.
There is no doubt however that there has been a hollowing out of our labour market. Somewhere we have lost around 600,000 who would normally have been productively employed.
This has also been described as a lifestyle choice with many deciding to opt out and to become economically inactive.
We are beginning to see what the real effects of this might be. We already know that large gaps have emerged in some of our key sectors. Support staff, care/ health workers and critically those in the hospitality, tourism and leisure sectors have become as hard to find as ‘hens teeth’.
What is very clear, is that Northern Devon has been particularly successful in attracting new investment during the last three years of turmoil. Many projects have been brought forward and are now ready to proceed but almost all of them will require either new or upgraded property.
The national situation is depressing. The current statistics made available from leading construction trade bodies describes the situation as both urgent and alarming.
It calculates the UK needs almost a million new plumbers, bricklayers and other trades over the next 10 years just to keep pace with demand. If nothing is done, the experts have calculated that by 2032 the actual number of skilled labourers needs to be increased by 937,000.
Another major factor here is that many of the existing skilled workforce are getting older. Roughly one in three are over 50 and are likely to retire in the next 10 years.
This situation is not being helped by increasing inflation and the overall cost of living crisis.
One of the main areas where shortages will arise is in the critical delivery of new homes. The government have set an ambitious target that want us to build 300,000 houses every year for the foreseeable future. This number is estimated as just sufficient to keep pace with demand.
In light of increased construction costs, huge difficulties in securing rapid planning permissions, enhanced demands for fire safety features in cladding and requirements to achieve Net Zero energy levels have all combined to make this problem a whole lot more difficult.
Informed experts estimate that we will be lucky to build much more than 110,000 during this coming year. Where does this leave first time buyers? What will it do to house prices? How much will this further increase the problems around the availability of affordable and rented accommodation?
Neither the government or industry have any realistic answers to these questions.
Another problem which is about to appear is how the country can achieve net zero by 2050. This will need a significant increase in trained construction workers, particularly, for example, plumbers who can install heat pumps.
It is apparent that in certain parts of the country there are huge gaps because of the lack of carpenters and electricians.
So are there any easy answers to this and what is the impact on many of Northern Devon’s hard fought successes in attracting new investments?
The normal solution to this is to ensure that there is a pipeline of trainees able to fill these gaps. The current estimate is that an average of 24,400 new construction apprentices are required each year.
This is a third more than the UK has produced in each of the past five years, in fact the number of people undertaking construction apprenticeships has fallen by an average of 11 per cent every year since 2017. These figures get worse when considering the proportion of those who start their apprenticeship but do not finish the course.
It is well known that there have been huge problems with the national apprenticeship schemes. The Coop Group, who are major supporters of these programmes, estimates that more than £600million of the apprenticeship levy funding has been wasted and sent back to government in 2022.
This budget alone would have been sufficient to fund more than 60,000 apprenticeships. Again, there are lots of good excuses why this is happening.
The British Retail Consortium probably have come up with the best solution which is that funds have been lost because businesses were unable to meet the red tape and restrictive requirements for drawing on money in the pot. Many would agree with this and also describe difficulties with inflexible courses, courses which are too long and the emergence of lower quality outcomes.
This is however a problem that we need to tackle on our own backyard. I have focused on the impact these shortages will have on the construction projects. This however is equally a problem for many other crucial sectors in our manufacturing/ business communities.
We have a brilliant college – Petroc – which is doing some ground-breaking work. The scale of the problem however is simply becoming unmanageable. This is one of those areas where waiting for Whitehall is not good enough.
The Northern Devon employment Skills Board is on the case but they need all our help to head off what will otherwise be a significant loss in our ability to deliver new investment and the wealth creation arising from this.