County takes first step in legal challenge to Devon council shake up

Cllr Julian Brazil speaks during a Devon County Council debateplaceholder image
Cllr Julian Brazil speaks during a Devon County Council debate | Devon County Council/YouTube

Devon County Council has begun the process to mount a potential legal challenge against the government’s plans for restructuring the region’s councils

The wheels have been set in motion to mount a legal challenge against the government’s plans to carve up Devon’s councils.

Devon County Council’s leader, Councillor Julian Brazil, said the council had sent a pre-action letter to the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government in the first step in the process to challenge the decision via a judicial review.

In July, Whitehall announced its chosen option for the local government restructure (LGR) process, which would see the county divided into four unitary authorities.

Exeter, Plymouth and Torbay would be expanded urban councils while the rest of the county would be lumped into a ‘coast and countryside’ council called Devon Council.

A pre-action protocol letter was sent to the secretary of state yesterday (Monday, August 3) as the first formal legal step before any claim is issued. A response from the government is expected within 14 days.

Cllr Brazil said: “I didn't come into local politics to increase taxes and deliver worse services; that's exactly what this decision risks doing.

“The government has chosen a model that prioritises urban expansion while failing to address the concerns of Devon's rural residents or the core services we deliver.

“I will not stand by while the most vulnerable people and deprived areas are ignored. Many residents know this decision does not reflect what is best for Devon as a whole.

“I am not opposed to local government reorganisation. What I oppose is the Government choosing this solution. It does not give sufficient weight to the needs of rural and coastal communities across Devon nor the most vulnerable we are here to serve.”

Cllr Brazil also renewed his call on the new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham and the new Local Government Secretary, Angela Rayner, to reconsider the decision taken by the previous administration.

He added: “We do not want to be in this position, but we have to consider all options available. We must do everything to protect the interests of Devon residents and if that means a judicial review, then so be it.

“If ministers are willing to engage further and reconsider the approach, that may avoid the need for formal proceedings.

“We were already working with our district council partners to deliver a more efficient and cost-effective council structure. The government's decision has put that work at risk leaving local taxpayers facing significant implementation costs estimated at £80million. Their model is heavily focused on urban areas, despite Devon being one of England's largest rural counties.

“There is, however, an opportunity for the new Government to engage with us. If ministers are serious about delivering growth and opportunity in every community, they should listen to the concerns being raised by Devon. The current proposal risks leaving many residents feeling overlooked while placing additional pressure on council tax bills.”

The region’s district councils including North Devon and Torridge had opted for a choice that would have put them in with Exeter, East Devon and Mid Devon.

Devon County Council has also submitted five freedom of information requests seeking details of how the Government reached its decision.

The authority is asking whether advice from officials, experts or ministers raised concerns about the expanded city model before the final decision was made.

The council's cabinet is expected to consider the position at its September meeting, which will include the full range of options up to a judicial review or other legal avenues.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice