“Costly shambles” of Devon council carve up is paused for review


The government is pausing the Local Government Restructure process to conduct a review - the unpopular plans would have seen county and district councils scrapped in 14 areas of England, including Devon
“A costly shambles” was the reaction to news the government is going to put plans to rip up Devon’s council map on hold while a review is carried out.
The Local Government Restructure plans would have seen existing district and county councils scrapped, the ‘city’ councils of Plymouth, Exeter and Torbay as stand alone councils and the rest of the county lumped into ‘Devon Council’, covering the ‘coast and countryside’.
But today (Monday, September 7) the government has announced restructure plans for Devon and 13 other areas in the country will now be paused while a review is carried out.
It said local elections for May of next year will now go ahead on existing council boundaries.
Communities Secretary Angela Rayner was set to announce the review in Parliament at around 3pm, citing “updated and privileged legal advice.”
She was expected to tell MPs: “In light of legal advice, I want to satisfy myself firstly that the right process is in place, that it is robust, and of course complies with the law".
“And secondly, I want to fully test whether our proposals for local government reorganisation meet the priorities of a new administration and a new prime minister and any additional considerations.”
Devon County Council had begun the process of applying for a judicial review to overturn the government’s earlier decision on restructuring the county.
The government was already facing legal challenges over proposals to reorganise councils in Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk – it said today the decisions on those councils had now been withdrawn.
Fremington county councillor Frank Biederman condemned the whole process as “a costly shambles.”
He said: “It looks like the threat of judicial reviews has finally made the Government think again about its Local Government Reorganisation plans.
“But the obvious question is: how many millions has this whole process already cost?
“Millions that could have been spent on our health services, fixing our roads, supporting our schools and actually improving local services, rather than creating months of uncertainty for council staff, residents and communities.”
Cllr Biederman said the estimated cost of restructuring Devon’s councils would have been around £80million and added: “This whole process has been rushed, hugely disruptive and incredibly expensive.
“Local government should be about delivering better services for local people, not politicians drawing boundaries on a map and forcing through a reorganisation that communities never asked for.
“It’s time to stop this shambles, listen to local people and put the money where it is actually needed.”
Ilfracombe county councillor Sara Wilson said her initial reaction was relief the plans were being paused.
She added: “The pace of decision-making was too fast, the way that Devon has been carved up is unfair on rural areas and the costs of doing all this run into the many millions.
“I hope this pause will allow time for a step back and re-evaluation - if we need to simplify local government, let’s do it with proper central government funding behind it and let’s have the process led by local authorities, not imposed by Whitehall.”