Committee agrees depot despite local concerns


New depot has been needed for 25 years
A village near Bideford is getting a new waste vehicle depot, even though at least 64 people don’t want it.
Torridge District Council says a depot for the district is a quarter of a century overdue and the plan for East-the-Water is the most suitable place it had considered over the years.
But there was concern over potential noise arising from the proposed facility at Manteo Way, which is just 35 metres from a residential development.
People are also worried about smells, air pollution, highway safety and loss of wildlife and habitats. Bideford Town Council also objects to the scheme.
Residents said the agricultural field should be left for housing as allocated in the local plan.
The council’s plans committee approved the new operational services centre by seven votes to one with one abstention after hearing that there is “a desperate need” for the depot. Cycle and pedestrian links in the area would also be improved and environmental enhancements made.
Four existing depots in Holsworthy, Torrington and Bideford, which are no longer fit for purpose, would all be incorporated into the one facility.
But Cllr Huw Thomas (Green, Bideford East), who voted against it, said given the strength of objection it wasn’t right that a council committee was making the decision, as every member was “biased in one way of another” and it should go to an independent planning inspector.
He agreed that the council needed a new base, but said it also needs homes as Torridge would need to increase housing by 35 per cent, in line with government targets.
“This is a charade,” he said. “There has been a lack of options given to both councillors and the public ,and a lack of scrutiny by councillors. It may well be the best option, but it wasn’t chosen in an open and democratic manner.”
Cllr Kit Hepple (Ind, Milton and Tamarside) wondered if the committee would come to the same conclusion had the application been made by a private company.
The consensus amongst 200 residents during the public consultation in April was that it wasn’t the right site.
The centre includes office space for employees working in waste and recycling and street cleansing, vehicle workshops and parking for the council’s 53 fleet vehicles.
Councillors were told it not be a waste transfer station, so black-bag domestic waste or processing of recycled domestic material would not be undertaken.
Half of waste, recycling and green waste collections for Torridge are within a 10 miles radius of the site and its proximity to the Instow Junction of the A39, provided good connectivity and direct access to material processing facilities in Brynsworthy, Barnstaple and Deepmoor, Great Torrington, said the council.
Cllr Jude Grubb (Ind, Bideford East) who lives on the nearby estate, said the site is too close to bungalows at Broadlands. She said it would devalue properties and there would be noise seven days a week starting at 5am and ending at 10pm.
The area is a haven for wildlife and a bat activity site and she feared that before long it would be “a fully blown recycling centre”.
But Cllr Chris Leather (Ind, Northam), lead member for operational services, didn’t believe there would be a detrimental impact.
“I think this proposal is fantastic,” he said.
He said there were no highways objections and, contrary to what some people thought, it would not cause traffic chaos on Alverdiscott Road, as lorries would travel along Manteo Way, and any noise, which he claimed would be minimal, would be shielded by the building.
He said the site would be well-screened and there would be a security fence and new hedgerows and the new cycleway would allow children to ride safely to school safely.
Cllr Doug Smith (Lib Dem, Great Torrington) said the council could not wait another 25 years for a depot as if there was going to be 35 per cent more households in the future it needed more facilities to cope.
The council’s head of legal and governance Staci Dorey said Torridge District Council was entirely separate from the planning committee.
“You have to have that differential in your mind,” she said.
“If you do not want to vote for it, the other option is to not decide it today and let it go to a planning inspectorate and they will determine it on the merits of the planning application.”
A proposal to refuse the application was not seconded.