Care home manager convicted over 2022 Roadford boating tragedy

The boating tragedy claimed two lives at Roadford Lake in June 2022. Credit: Derek Harper/Geographplaceholder image
The boating tragedy claimed two lives at Roadford Lake in June 2022. Credit: Derek Harper/Geograph

Two residents from Burdon Grange Care Home died and a third was badly injured when a wheelchair-accessible boat capsized at Roadford Lake, with the then home manager in court today (Tuesday, June 16)

The manager who was in charge of a Beaworthy care home when two residents died and a third was injured in a boating accident on Roadford Lake has been fined following a CQC prosecution.

Today (Tuesday, June 16) Janice Sowden, 60, the former manager of Burdon Grange Care Home, was ordered to pay £4,090 at Exeter Magistrates’ Court for her role in the 2022 tragedy which claimed the lives of Alison Tilsley and Alex Wood.

Ms Sowden pled guilty to failing to provide safe care and treatment to three people, resulting in avoidable harm to them.

The court fined her £1,900 and she was also ordered to pay a £190 victim surcharge and £2,000 costs. 

In October last year, the home operator, Burdon Grange Care Home Limited pled guilty to similar charges and was ordered to pay more than £200,000.

Ms Tilsley, who was known as Ali, was one of the Burdon Grange residents who died when the boat overturned.placeholder image
Ms Tilsley, who was known as Ali, was one of the Burdon Grange residents who died when the boat overturned.

The court heard how on June 8, 2022 Janice Sowden arranged an external activity for six people who lived at Burdon Grange Care Home, all of whom were wheelchair users, on an outing to Roadford Lake Activity Centre.

The group hired a wheelchair-accessible boat from the activity centre, known as a Wheelyboat for a trip on the lake.

While on the lake, the boat carried three of the six residents from the home. The boat took on water and capsized, resulting in the deaths of two people, Alison Tilsley and Alex Wood and serious harm to a third, Kate Dart.

The CQC (Care Quality Commission) said the provider, manager and staff failed to assess the risks of the boat trip and did not take reasonable, practical steps to manage the risks for the highly vulnerable people in their care.

Staff also failed to plan for what would happen if service users entered the water. One staff member present could not swim.

Burdon Grange Care Home near Beaworthyplaceholder image
Burdon Grange Care Home near Beaworthy | Google Street View

A report by the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) previously found that South West Lakes Trust (SWLT), which owned the activity centre that ran the boat trip, had not maintained the vessel or considered the risks.

It stated Ms Tilsley and Mr Wood were strapped into their wheelchairs and drowned after the boat overturned and they were dragged to the bottom of the lake.

The investigation also found that water had leaked into the vessel and seals on the bow ramp had degraded which resulted in capsizing, concluding the boat had not been properly maintained.

Speaking aftger the prosecution of Ms Sowden, Stefan Kallee, CQC deputy director of adult social care in the South West, said: “Our sympathies are with the family and friends of Alison Tilsley, Alex Wood and with Kate Dart who experienced serious harm.

“People receiving care and treatment have the right to expect that any risks to their safety will be effectively managed. This isn’t what happened when they were in the care of Janice Sowden and Burdon Grange Care Home.

“The majority of adult social care organisations do a great job. However, when people in the care of a service come to harm, we will take action to hold them to account and to protect people in future.

“This fine is not representative of the value of Alison and Alex’s lives or the injuries that Kate suffered, but I hope this prosecution acts as a reminder to all adult social care services and the managers of their duty to assess and manage all risks to ensure people are kept safe.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice