Sally Allen: Debenhams site must be done right for Torbay’s future

Calls grow for bold thinking, public input and better design on the harbourfront development
Sorry everyone, but I am going to address the thorny issue that is the Debenhams site. This is probably the most important site in the whole of Torbay and we therefore need to ensure that we get it right for now and future generations of residents and tourists.
Firstly, I would like to know if the opportunity to design the harbourfront area has been put out to tender? It is normal that at least three firms of architects be asked to submit ideas before settling on one.
It is also important that the decision on the design is not left to councillors but put out for a vote from the public.
It is important financially and as well as creatively to be able to get the best options on the table. Even better is an open tender whereby any firm can apply to enable a short list of options to be prepared.
However, the best route, in my opinion, is to run an international design competition. This way Torbay receives international media attention whilst getting the very best talents to create ideas for this hugely important space.
The current CAD design, although with a pastel wash over it to enhance its look, is yet another concrete block which wouldn’t be out of place in Eastern Europe when it was behind the Iron Curtain.
Whatever is built along our harbourside will hopefully be there for generations and let’s not forget that tourists do not visit to check out the concrete brutalist designs, what interests them is either seeing something completely different and exciting or beautiful heritage assets.
As the majority of our heritage assets have been demolished in favour of ill thought through ugly replacements – remember the beautiful Spa building to name but one – we surely must take the utmost care with the harbourside.
It is not pie in the sky because it has been done before. The MCC (Marylebone Cricket Club) was a client of mine and we ran an international architectural competition to build a new media centre at Lord’s Cricket Club in time for the 1999 World Cup.
There were numerous entries, some looked like a traditional pavilion and others were exciting but not suitable. When asked by Chris Rea, head of marketing for MCC and a former Scotland rugby international, which design did I think I could raise the necessary sponsorship for to cover the building costs, in my view there was no contest.
So, in 1995, I secured sponsorship from NatWest to have the naming rights to this fantastic building. Unlike other traditional event spaces, the media centre has become an architectural icon.
Designed by the award-winning firm Future Systems, it was the world’s first all-aluminium, boat-built building — a striking, aerodynamic structure that won the prestigious Stirling Prize for Architecture.
Its futuristic design is a bold contrast to the heritage of Lord’s, making it an extraordinary talking point for guests and tourists. It has been a massive success and subsequently the MCC has continued in their eclectic choices that blend with each other in what is now considered the most beautiful sports stadium in the world.
We need help to think outside the box sometimes and our harbourside is in desperate need of it. Surely, it cannot be decided on one rather grim and unimaginative block to house a 154-bedroom hotel.
This is described as a boutique hotel and it isn’t. A boutique hotel has fewer than 100 rooms. The proposed hotel has two more rooms than Hotel Indigo. I have asked if it would be a five-star hotel and initially I was assured it would be, but when pressed and having explained the requirements for a five-star, the conversation changed and it was quickly downgraded to a good four-star.
There are two other hotels in very close proximity and although they are very much the economy end of the market, it doesn’t appear that anything gets properly thought through.
To make anything successful there is a need for joined up thinking. This all appears to be a thought process that owes more to knee jerk reaction with no thought of how it will fit in with everything else. It is vital that any development around the harbour is sympathetic to the surrounding environment.
It is also rumoured that the ground floor of the development will house a range of restaurants. No doubt more downmarket additions to the already crowded offering around the harbour.
We now have some really good hospitality spots in this area and the best ones are always independents not national chains, which are guaranteed to downgrade the feel, look and even smell of the area.
How is it that there are still two very large units still empty yards away from the proposed development. Why haven’t these been let?
They have now been empty for a number of years so there isn’t exactly a queue to take space. Add to this that there are no facilities for guests to park within the proposed new hotel building so I understand they will have to rely upon valet parking or park their cars in what is left of the Terrace car park.
A substantial number of spaces were removed to allow the construction of the Premier Inn hotel and there is already a restricted area for sole use of the Hampton by Hilton Hotel and the Premier Inn itself.
Guests at these hotels pay a daily fee to park there. It is therefore a fair assumption that a further number of spaces in this car park would also be reserved for exclusive use of the new hotel’s guests as well. All this means that there is unlikely to be any, or very little, space left for shoppers or tourists.
Another point which surely has to be considered is that a five-story building in a mainly two-story neighbourhood could be considered tall.
The proposal to replace the two-storey Debenhams building with a five to six-storey building is indisputably classed as inappropriate.
Something else to consider is unfortunately, the Hampton by Hilton development, whose foundations are in Torwood Street, is still built to the same height of the terrace buildings, not Torwood Street. This has set a precedent that the new hotel designers are likely to take full advantage of and construct their own building to a similar height as the Terrace buildings too.
Then the other very serious point. The Fragrance Group bought the Palace Hotel site on the promise of building a wonderful five-star hotel but have subsequently dumped that idea as they have now decided that it is no longer viable.
I am suspicious of their motives, but the Palace site is far more suitable as a hotel site with lots of parking, gardens and other facilities. If they do not intend to go forward, they should be encouraged to sell to a developer who will build a 5-star hotel.
So, let’s take a breath, let’s truly consider what the town needs and what the harbourside needs and deserves and will not look out of place in 100 years, before erecting yet another monstrosity. To run an international architectural competition would create enormous interest. We owe it to Torbay, ourselves and future generations.