Grecians react as Matt Taylor is named as Exeter City’s next permanent manager

Exeter City re appointment of former Exeter City Manager, Matt Taylor at St James Park, Exeter, Devon on 14 May 2026. Photo: Phil Mingo/PPAUKplaceholder image
Exeter City re appointment of former Exeter City Manager, Matt Taylor at St James Park, Exeter, Devon on 14 May 2026. Photo: Phil Mingo/PPAUK

Exeter City have confirmed the return of promotion-winning manager Matt Taylor on a permanent basis, but supporters remain divided after the club’s difficult end to the season

Exeter City have appointed Matt Taylor as the club’s permanent first-team manager, marking a return to St James Park for the man who led the Grecians to promotion from League Two in 2022.

The club confirmed Taylor’s appointment on Thursday evening following what chairman Wilf Walsh described as a thorough recruitment process involving candidates from “multiple sources”, including applicants through the League Managers Association.

Taylor, who first joined Exeter as a player in 2006, returns alongside assistant manager Dan Green, who has signed a new contract. 

Kevin Nicholson will also remain part of the coaching staff.

In a statement, Mr Walsh said Taylor’s understanding of the club’s supporter-owned model and academy pathway made him the standout candidate.

“A number of criteria were set for the position, particularly around our supporter ownership model and the importance of the need to bring young players through our Academy,” he said.

“He understands every aspect of the Club. He knows how to get promoted out of League Two and he is absolutely committed to the Academy and the model of developing young players which has been so successful for us in recent years.”

Taylor managed Exeter between 2018 and 2022, overseeing 227 matches and recording 103 wins, 61 draws and 63 defeats before leaving for Rotherham United in October of 2022.

His second spell began on an interim basis towards the end of last season, but results proved difficult. Exeter won one of his 13 games in charge, drawing five and losing seven.

The club said his reappointment forms part of a wider “reset” focused on financial sustainability and developing academy talent.

Speaking after his appointment, Taylor said: “Coming back to Exeter reminded me just how special this Club is.

“There’s work to do, on and off the pitch, as the whole Club goes through something of a reset and I’m excited to be part of this.

“We know we will need to rely on the young players, ideally through the academy system and this is one area where I have a great deal of experience.”

He also thanked supporters for their backing during his two decades of involvement with the club.

“We want to have more local players, players who have grown up in the area and truly reflect the fact they are ‘one of our own’,” he said.

Reaction among supporters has been mixed, with some fans questioning the decision following the club’s recent form.

One supporter, Mr Keens, told Exeter Today: “Personally it’s a bipolar one for me. I feel as if there’s the integrity of Taylor’s past at City in League Two where he was phenomenal and could work under restricted budgets but coming off the back of last season where it was a tough campaign, my confidence in him has dropped.”

Social media responses to the announcement also reflected divided opinion.

One supporter wrote: “Why? He’s only won one game since he’s been back. Absolutely crazy decision.”

Another posted: “Sorry - wrong decision. MT had his time here and chose Rotherham over us. We need a new face with new ideas.”

Others have welcomed the decision to retain assistant manager Dan Green, who is highly regarded by supporters for his work with younger players.

Replying to the club’s announcement, one fan wrote: “Great news. Hopefully he can build himself up towards the main job in the future.”

Another added: “Now that’s the best news.”

Taylor’s managerial career has also included spells at Rotherham United and Bristol Rovers. 

As a player, he represented clubs including Charlton Athletic, Bradford City, Cheltenham Town and Newport County.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice