A massive final at a small ground presents National League with problems


Torquay United's trip to Hornchurch raises the question of stadium suitability
If it isn’t already on the agenda for this month’s National League annual meeting, then ‘Arrangements For Play-Off Finals’ should certainly be added to Any Other Business.
If any proof were needed, it was in the series of urgent phone calls and online meetings that took place last Saturday night and Sunday morning as officials of the League and NL South finalists Hornchurch and Torquay United tried to grapple with the issues surrounding this weekend’s final at the Hornchurch Stadium.
There had even been rumours that it might be switched, as league rules allow, to a nearby neutral ground. Leyton Orient’s Brisbane Road had been mentioned.
For as soon as Hornchurch beat Weston-super-Mare to join the Gulls in the final, everyone knew there was a problem.
By the way, we aren’t about to start on a Hornchurch-bashing drive here.
When the League expanded the Play-Offs from four to six clubs, they included the incentive that the second and third-placed teams would miss the ‘Eliminator’ round, be guaranteed a home Semi-Final and the surviving team with the highest league position would host the Final.
Fine. Hornchurch have done nothing wrong.
They have come a long way in a comparatively short time, including an FA Trophy triumph in 2021 and promotion as Isthmian League champions two years ago.
They have made improvements to the Hornchurch Stadium, which is essentially an athletics arena, like nearby Chelmsford City’s Melbourne Stadium.
Crowds that used to number a few hundred now average 1,000, which is never a problem in a ground with a 3,000 capacity.
Facilities there may not match those at bigger, older-established clubs in the NL South – they may well have to improve them further if they reach the NL Premier – but the league have obviously been content that they meet the required criteria.
All this is perfectly OK for regular-season run-of-the-mill match purposes.
But Saturday’s Final is not a run-of-the-mill match.
It is, as Torquay co-chairman Michael Westcott described it, ‘a showpiece occasion’. It’s especially ‘awkward’ that Torquay United are there.
Their average crowds (3,500) aren’t just far ahead of any other club in the NLS, they would place them sixth in the NL Premier.
An allocation of 900 tickets for the Gulls – it’s actually 150 more than they are strictly entitled to – was never going to be remotely enough.
For the extraordinary number of supporters who follow United away come rain or shine, it must feel as if they put thousands of pounds through other clubs’ turnstiles every other week and then, when the biggest game of all comes along, they’re treated like an inconvenience.
But don’t let’s pretend that all this has arisen just because it’s Torquay going to Hornchurch.
Wouldn’t similar problems have cropped up if the final had been between Hornchurch and, say, Chelmsford or Dagenham & Redbridge?
As Westcott also said, after doing his best to make the most of a devilishly difficult job at the weekend, ‘It is what it is’.
But the lesson for the League must surely be that, while regular matches are one thing and Play-Off rules can still favour the higher finishing clubs, there must be bigger and better minimum ground requirements for staging a Final.
Now, let’s see if that comes up under Any Other Business later this month?
Meanwhile, Well Done to United for laying on big-screen coverage of the match at Plainmoor, and Good Luck to all the fans trying to get tickets.
If the atmosphere at Weston, Slough and Tonbridge recently is anything to go by, it’ll almost feel like a home game anyway..!