Appeal victory for Bideford ‘village green’ preservation campaigners


An area of green open space in Bideford used by residents for years has been saved from development after a planning inspector rejected an appeal from Pearce Construction
A piece of open space in Bideford which has been enjoyed by families for half a century has been saved from development.
Torridge District Council planning officers said objections from residents were significant after an appeal decision upheld plans to refuse a new home on an infill site used as a village green at High Park Close.
The planning committee refused the application by Pearce Construction Ltd in February, but this was challenged by the developer.
Pearce Construction argued at the appeal the site was not officially designated as public open space and was privately owned, but the council said it performed an important function and had been used by residents over a long period of time.
Defined as public highway, the 250 square metres site had been maintained by the county council all this time.
Residents said open space was at a premium in that area. One said: “This is the only open grassy area that we have, which has been used by residents walking their dogs and children to play on for 50 years.
“It has been maintained by the council and is a HMPE (highways maintainable at public expense) site which we have paid for through our council tax.”
The planning inspector dismissed the appeal, concluding that it was an “unacceptable loss of green infrastructure” and for this reason was in conflict with the council’s policies.
Bideford Councillor David Brenton has urged the community to apply to get the land officially registered as a village green so it is protected for the future.
At a planning meeting this week, he said this was a very good outcome for local people – 12 of whom objected officially to the proposal through the council’s planning portal – and he hoped this appeal result would send a message to “professional people” who wanted to build on any “small plot of land you can lay your hands on or most inappropriate ones.”
Cllr Brenton said the level of public open space in Torridge was below what it should be at the current time.
Planning manager Helen Smith said: “The inspector acknowledged the site is privately owned and lacks formal designation, but that current policy in local plan is strong enough to mean it is identified as public open space and should be retained for that purpose.
“A really important point with this was the level of contribution and objection from the local community and the inspector put great weight to that. He recognised the value of it to the public.”
The committee chair, Cllr Rosemary Lock said there was also a message here to the public about the importance of expressing their views and submitting them to the council.
She added: “Most people think it’s a waste of time to put in their comments because no one takes any notice but in this case they did.”
Councillors were told there was a similar case in Torrington near the primary school where a privately owned piece that was used as public open space was also saved from development on appeal.