Anger over ‘secret’ unelected body that sets Devon speed limits


North Devon and other Devon councillors call for more transparency on setting speed limits on local roads as the decisions are currently taken behind closed doors
Councillors have called for more openness after claiming an unelected ‘secret group’ is making decisions on Devon speed limits behind closed doors.
Members of Devon County Council have raised their concerns over SCARF (Speed Compliance Action Review Forum) deciding on whether to change or enforce speed limits on some of the county’s speeding blackspots without consulting local councillors or the community.
It was raised at a full meeting of Devon County Council, which is part of SCARF in conjunction with Devon and Cornwall Police.
Fremington county councillor Frank Biederman said he had concerns about the process and the level of democratic scrutiny and involvement of local ward members.
Cllr Biederman said he has pushed for the council to “urgently review” a decision to hold the speed limit at 40mph on the B3233 between Fremington and Instow, claiming the significant volume of traffic on it is negatively impacting the lives of residents.
He said: “The reality is that in Yelland, it has grown so much with significant development – upwards of 1,000 homes – and the number of car movements that creates is huge.
“Every door I knock on in Yelland, the residents tell me they fear crossing the road. They have to stand there forever for an opportunity to cross, but with the size of vehicles, they fear leaving their homes and they are becoming socially isolated.”
He added he was “fed up” with SCARF because it seemed to be a “blockage to getting anything done in our communities.”


Chulmleigh councillor Ed Tyldesley added: “I appreciate SCARF is data-led, but the experience of living by a road is not exclusively about data, but about feelings too, and we as councillors would like to provide the local feelings about how a road is experienced by residents.”
Councillor Alan Connett asked for more transparency about the SCARF committee and process.
He said: “I ask the highways cabinet member whether he agrees that we need to pull the curtain back and let light into the secret process of SCARF meetings and to have them in the diary so local members are informed about when they are happening.”
In response, highways member Cllr Dan Thomas said: “In terms of ‘opening up the darkness’, as Cllr Connett says, I note the wish to let councillors know when meetings have happened and the minutes of them.
“But if councillors want to attend, that is going to be a potential stumbling block in the sense that the SCARF process is very much fact and risk-based and it has been free of politicisation, something we as councillors inherently bring with us.
“If the suggestion is that we attend but don’t speak, that could be welcomed, but I don’t put much money on that happening.”
Cllr Thomas said he would discuss the issue further with Cllr Connett “on a way forward that allows democracy in.”
Concerns about speeding and speed limits can be raised to SCARF via a web page on the Devon County Council website.
If it is felt further investigation is needed, those areas are put through a speed detection assessment for data to be gathered and that could lead to no action, education or enforcement, or even engineering changes to the road layout.
The web page says the method used for its speed analysis looks at the mean or average speed and the 85th percentile speed – meaning the speed at which 85 per cent of drivers travel at or below – to determine if there is an issue.
In an example, it states that in a 30mph speed limit, a mean speed of 30mph would normally be expected to have an 85th percentile speed of no greater than 35mph.
It explains the five potential outcomes, ranging from a ‘Level 0’ – which is no action – to ‘Level 4’ – which is mobile camera enforcement or an engineered solution to the road.
You can find out more about the SCARF process and report speeding issues at https://www.devon.gov.uk/roads-and-transport/safe-travel/road-safety/safer-roads/speeding-and-speed-limits