Don't miss a story sign up to the North Devon Gazette's FREE daily newsletter CLICK HERE

‘No council tax until you clean up my garden’

07:08 08 August 2012

Julia Daunt and Paul Fiddian say they are prepared to go to court after refusing to hand over council tax to North Devon Council.

Julia Daunt and Paul Fiddian say they are prepared to go to court after refusing to hand over council tax to North Devon Council.


Barnstaple couple say they will not pay their taxes until district council fixes ‘contaminated’ gasworks site.

A BARNSTAPLE couple say they are prepared to face court and even jail after withholding their council tax payments.

Julia Daunt and partner Paul Fiddian say they feel ‘completely let down’ by North Devon Council following its handling of a planning application for the clean up of the old Barbican Close gasworks.

They claim their house is now sitting on ground contaminated by lead, cyanide and other hazardous substances, following the decommissioning of the former industrial site prior to development.

At the time Julia, Paul and around a dozen residents said they had been made ill by the work, with headaches, dizziness and other symptoms.

The couple are refusing to pay any more council tax, alleging the council made a mess of the planning process and did not carry out adequate monitoring of the work, carried out by contractors on behalf of owner National Grid.

“I am prepared to go to court over this and I would quite happily go to prison,” Julia told the Gazette, shortly after receiving a final demand from the council and a warning of court proceedings.

“I don’t care about the repercussions because they have had since I first told them about the contamination to deal with it, but they haven’t done so.

“We had independent tests done before they did the work, when the results came back normal and twice afterwards, when they came back abnormal.”

The surveys were carried out by Red Rock Geoscience Ltd, geotechnical and geo-environmental consultants.

A report by the company showed up to twice the recommended human health guideline amount of lead in all soil samples, among other elevated levels of some metals and chemicals. The couple say the groundwater is also contaminated, although the most recent testing followed heavy rain and did not show high levels.

The risk rating associated with these pollutants ranged from low to moderate, but worryingly, Red Rock suggested concentrations of lead in the top soil could potentially pose a risk to young children through ingestion of soils and home-grown vegetables.

The couple have been advised not to eat anything grown from the soil in their garden.

“Although National Grid did the work, I think the buck stops with North Devon Council,” added Julia.

“We want them to pay for or to clean up our garden and remedy the problem. Who is going to pay for our garden to be cleaned-up? Who is going to want to buy our house? Our home has been ruined.

“They have a duty of care and we are not paying council tax to a council that won’t do its job properly.”

She said they had paid the first two council tax instalments to ensure they contributed towards the police and fire service.

A North Devon Council spokesperson said: “We can’t discuss individual cases. However, as with other cases of non-payment of council tax, normal recovery procedures will be followed.”

1 comment

  • I completely agree with Miss Daunt and Mr Fiddian. Speaking as an ex Barbican resident, know how good the gardens are for growing fruit vegetables and various flowers and herbs, the council gave the go ahead for this scheme knowing full well that their could be a risk of contaminants from the old gas works site. The staff working there were given protective face masks and meters which would sound an alarm should the toxins in the air become harmful, so if they were given all this, why weren't the residents? The council are partially at fault and as such should be held accountable even at part for the contamination of the soils, health problems, environmental affects and loss of earnings due to illness.

    Report this comment

    Phil Knight

    Thursday, August 9, 2012

Other News Stories

Yesterday, 14:00
Is the row over dogs back at Instow beach?

Parish Council meeting on Thursday, October 15 to review the situation

Read more
Yesterday, 13:40
Residents protest against the plans at the site in March. Picture: Jim Bell

Benefits outweigh the harm, says Government inspector

Read more
Yesterday, 11:37
Get your chickens an Eglu and help raise money for the British Hen Welfare Trust today (Friday).

Support for British Hen Welfare Trust from the Omlet Eglu

Read more
Yesterday, 10:33
Police are trying to track the car in this picture

The owner of a blue Nissan Almeira could have vital information on collision that killed Natalie Jones, say police

Read more
Yesterday, 09:23
John Balls with Clovelly caught lobsters.

Lobster fisherman has reached a landmark in his bid to help conservation at Clovelly

Read more
Yesterday, 09:16

September saw a 4.9 per cent increase in crime in Barnstaple on the same period last year.

Read more
Yesterday, 09:14
Portmore's Colin and Mandy Webber presented the cheque to representatives of the club's chosen charities

Five local charities are to benefit from another year of fundraising at Portmore Golf Club.

Read more
Thu, 17:17

Fire called out to help in the early hours of Thursday morning

Read more
Thu, 13:20
A busy Woolacombe Bay. North Devon has seen a welcome late summer boost in tourism this year

Tourism sectors across the region are reaping the benefits as a result of the late summer sunshine.

Read more
Thu, 12:06
Giant veg grower David Maund picked up a number of placings at the Malvern Autumn Show

A giant-vegetable grower from Bideford has returned from a national competition with a prize haul almost as big as some of his extraordinary exhibits.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 14°C

min temp: 9°C

Most Read News

Great British Life

Great British Life

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
North Devon Football League
Order Photos
Family notices
Google Plus Page
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the North Devon Gazette e-edition E-edition

Search for a job in Devon

Local business directory

North Devon's trusted business finder

Find planning applications