Don't miss a story sign up to the North Devon Gazette's FREE daily newsletter CLICK HERE

Devon County Council care closures to be ‘challenged’

11:43 18 June 2014

Signs of protest by Oakwell Care Home in Bickington.

Signs of protest by Oakwell Care Home in Bickington.


Decision to close care homes and day centres to be ‘called in’ by council’s own scrutiny committee.

A DECISION to close 20 council-run care homes and 17 day care centres across Devon is expected to be challenged by Devon County Council’s own scrutiny committee, the Gazette understands.

On Monday, it was announced that Beech House in South Molton; Burrow House in Ilfracombe; Lydiate Lodge at Lynton; Fairlea in Northam; and Oakwell in Bickington are among the homes set to close, meaning residents will now have to seek similar care from the private sector.

County-wide, only two homes will remain, specialist dementia units in Torrington and Newton Abbot.

Of the 11 North Devon day centres marked for closure, five will go – Springfield and Quayside in Bideford; Beech House in South Molton; Burrow House in Ilfracombe; and a hub at the Plough in Torrington.

But Oakwell in Bickington, and Barnstaple-based Rosebank, Silverhill, Tarka and Greenfields will be retained as a new ‘integrated service’ at a site still to be decided.

The future of the Oasis day centre in Barnstaple is still unclear.

As the Gazette went to press yesterday (Tuesday), Liberal Democrat and non-aligned county councillors were making moves to ‘call in’ the Conservative-led cabinet’s decision.

Frank Biederman, independent county councillor for Fremington Rural, was one of three members, along with Lib Dem councillors Alan Connett and Alastair Dewhurst, hoping to refer the decision to the council’s own ‘People’s Scrutiny Committee’.

Mr Biederman told the Gazette: “We are challenging the decision on the grounds that the evidence base the council has used is flawed.

“We don’t believe there is alternative or equivalent care elsewhere in the community.

“The decision has to be called in by three member of the scrutiny committee within five days and a special meeting will have to be arranged to enable us to ask the cabinet to look at this again.”

Unison has called the decision ‘shameful’, saying it would result in more than 1,000 job loses and leave more 400 vulnerable adults facing an uncertain future.

But councillor Stuart Barker, the council’s cabinet member for adult social care, said a phased closure of homes and day centres over the next 18 months was the ‘only way’ the authority could plug a £200million Government funding gap.

He said: “Nothing will happen immediately. This is a process that will take time and we will do this with great care and sensitivity.

“In taking the decisions I want to ensure that everyone who is entitled to have a service from us gets it, be it residential care or a day service, and that they will continue to receive a service that meets their needs.”

Read more reaction to this story at

What do you think? Email or write to the usual address.

1 comment

  • I am totally appalled at the decision to close these care homes & agree fully with Mr Biederman that it will be impossible to find equivalent care elsewhere in the community.My mother has been a resident at Oakwell for 3 years & the care she receives is outstanding.She is 83years old & suffers from severe vascular dementia,to move her now would be life threatening.Oakwell is a centre of excellence for dementia care & should be expanded not closed.

    Report this comment

    Lyn Parker

    Wednesday, June 18, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Other News Stories

A busy Woolacombe Bay. North Devon has seen a welcome late summer boost in tourism this year

Tourism sectors across the region are reaping the benefits as a result of the late summer sunshine.

Read more
5 minutes ago

Fire called out to help in the early hours of Thursday morning

Read more
Giant veg grower David Maund picked up a number of placings at the Malvern Autumn Show

A giant-vegetable grower from Bideford has returned from a national competition with a prize haul almost as big as some of his extraordinary exhibits.

Read more
Picture: Michelle Turner

After six weeks couple are reunited with their beloved pet following a huge search effort

Read more
Members of the Acland family gather at the restored Acland memorial in Landkey Church.

St Paul’s Parish Church hosts a rededication service for its newly restored Acland Chapel – with special guests in attendance

Read more
Keith and Gilly Pugsley with their new book, Do-it-Yourself Life Mechanics.

Combe Martin couple create a DIY guide to improving the mechanics of your life

Read more
Olive and Cyril Milburn.

Torrington couple celebrate 60 years together - and reveal their secrets to a long and happy marriage.

Read more
Yesterday, 16:02
A new northern breakwater sheltering the harbour would be a huge boost to Ilfracombe.

‘If you don’t ask, you don’t get’: North Devon Council has lodged funding bids asking for tens of millions of pounds

Read more
Yesterday, 13:31
Money is being set aside to expand Sticklepath Community School in Barnstaple. Picture: Andy Keeble

Council expected to rubber stamp half-a-million-pound scheme to boost pupil numbers in west of town.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:59
Newcross Barnstaple branch manage Alix Ripley is welcomed on board by operations director Geoff White. Picture: Submitted

Firm expands into North Devon with full-time positions for more than 100 healthcare professionals

Read more

Local Weather



max temp: 15°C

min temp: 9°C

Most Read News

Great British Life

Great British Life

Useful Links

Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Subscribe to the paper
North Devon Football League
Order Photos
Family notices
Google Plus Page
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the North Devon Gazette e-edition E-edition

Search for a job in Devon

Local business directory

North Devon's trusted business finder

Find planning applications